How do you choose yours?
I have been using one design from the same design team for most of the years.
When you choose computers, camera, mobile phone/cell phone, etc,
would you use some professional websites'
interactive side-by-side comparision of product features/specifications
to narrow down your choices?
I had used Fancl's HanaNoTeChou Flower Diary in 2006, 2007, 2011, 2012.
In some years, I have also used MassMutual Insurance Company Hong Kong pocket diary,
Sun Life Financial (Hong Kong) pocket diary. They are more for business persons. Lots of pages & informations. A bit on the heavy side.
!! To designers & publishers,
please notice the hand sizes of females
if you want to steer your products towards female consumer market..
Ergonomics. Body measurement.
Please also note the size difference in
Oriental females & Western white females.
say... the UK size 10 vs UK size 16 ?!
After much comparison...
here I share a big wide table ...
TYPE of Diary |
Pocket Diary / Briefcase | Pocket Diary |
Pocket Diary |
Pocket Diary | Pocket Diary |
Pocket Diary |
Pocket Diary | Pocket Diary / Briefcase | Home Use |
Student / academic | Student / academic |
Country | UK | Japan | Japan | Japan | Japan | UK | Japan | Japan | UK | UK | UK |
Organisations | Gilt Edged Promotion Ltd, UK | FANCL
Japan |
Daiso Japan |
Daiso Japan | FANCL
Japan |
Paper
Rose / Robert Frederick Ltd. |
Daiso Japan | Midori
Japan / DesignPhil Japan |
National Trust | The Works | ? Distributed by H&O in Birmingham, UK |
Diary | Gilt Edged Promotion 2017 diary | Fancl -Hana No TeChou (Flower Diary ) | Daiso Schedule Diary . | Daiso A6 Diary | Fancl -Hana No TeChou (Flower Diary) | Paper Rose Diary | Daiso Monthly Schedule Book | Midori Diary - Professional | National Trust Engagements Diary | Academic Calendar | Academic Diary Mid- Year |
Series | Senator
15 months |
Monday version. There is also Sunday version. | No.15. Japanese style pattern; floral. | A6
Diary girl -no.21, Menina |
Spirit -Fine Art Collection - Francesca | Floral | Business/ professional | / | / | / | |
version | 2017 | 2017 | 2017 | 2017 | 2016 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2017 | 2016 -2017 |
2015 -2016 |
Period | 13 months |
14
months |
16
months |
15
months |
14 months |
12
months |
18
months |
14
months |
12 months |
12
months |
12 months |
Start | 2016.10.03 | 2016.11.28 | 2016.10 | 2016.10 | 2015.11.29 | 2015.12.28 | 2014.10 | 2013.12 | 2016.12.26 | 2016.08.01 | 2015.07.27 |
End | 2017.12.31 | 2017.02.04 | 2018.01 | 2017.12 | 2017.02.04 | 2017.01.01 | 2016.03 | 2014.12 | 2017.12.31 | 2017.07.31 | 2016.07.31 |
Dimension Type | Slim | Slim | A6 | Slim | Slim | Slim | A5 | ||||
Width, w sleeve |
10.3 cm | 8.3 cm | 10 cm | 10.7 cm | 8.3 cm | 8.5 cm | 9.7 cm | 12.5 cm | 13.5 cm | 16.2 cm | 15.2 cm |
Length, w sleeve |
17.3 cm | 15.3 cm | 18.5 cm | 14.9 cm | 14.3 cm | 16 cm | 14.8 cm | 21.3 cm | 17.5 cm | 21.5 cm | 20.9 cm |
Thickness total | 1.5 cm | 0.8 cm | 0.4 cm | 0.5 cm | 0.8 cm | 1.1 m | 0.5 cm | 0.8 cm | 1 cm | 1 cm | 0.5 cm |
WEIGHT | 160 g | 100 g | 75 g | 80 g | 100 g | 120 g | 80 g | 180 g | 200 g | 200 g | 160 g |
Bound | Spirolux | Section Sewn | Saddle | Saddle | Section Sewn | Section Sewn | Saddle | Section Sewn | Spiral, coated metal | Section Sewn | Spiral, metal |
Language | Englsih | Japanese | English & Japanese | English & Japanese | English | English | English & Japanese | English & Japanese | English | English | English |
Pages | 180 | 160 | 64 | 64 | 160 | 156 | 80 | 100 | 110 | 132 | 128 |
Paper colour | cream | white | white | cream | white | white | white | cream | white | white | white |
Sleeve | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | ||||
Sleeve feature | card slots | pen holder, pocket | pen holder, pocket | ||||||||
Sleeve material | Synthetic material. Smooth. Thick. | PVC - transparent, light weight | PVC - transparent, light weight | PVC - transparent, light weight | PVC - transparent, light weight | Hard cover | PVC - transparent, light weight | Synthetic Material | |||
Cover Graphics | Embossed with a company name of Charcroft Electronics | Photo
image of colourful Ranaculus flowers - double flower type in a glass vase. |
Illustration of Chrysanthemum of 4 colours on white background | Illustration
in pastel colours: girl with present and text: "The day when every day is new and fun" on white background |
Photo image of roses on light blue background |
Illustration
of abstract floral |
Illustraton
of abstract floral patter in pastal colours and gold. Title text in metalic gold. |
/ | Close up colour photo image of Agapanthis flowers. | mocking illustration of Scrabble. | Illustration
of 24 colourful watercolour circles on semi- transparent background |
Cover Colour | Dark blue | Multi-colour | Multi-colour | Multi-colour | Blue, dark blue, white, purple | Almost black with leather texture | Mainly green, purple, white | Dusty colours | Multi-colour | ||
Cover Material | Cardboard. Hard cover. | Cardboard. Hard Cover. | |||||||||
Content: Number of ink colours for main body | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 |
Year Planners | Good | Good | Good | / | Good | / | / | Good | / | Grey boxes | Too small to write |
Week start | Monday | Monday | Monday | Monday | Sunday | Monday | Monday | Monday | Monday | Monday | Monday |
week view | one week on two facing pages | two weeks on two facing pages | / | / | two weeks on two facing pages | one week on two facing pages | / | / | One week | one week on two facing pages | one week on two facing pages |
Month view | as tiny inset on Sundays | Month view on two facing pages; also as inset in weekly view. | Month view on two facing pages | Month view on two facing pages | Month view on two facing pages; also as inset in weekly view. | / | Month view on two facing pages. With next month calendar as small inset. | Month view on two facing pages | / | / | / |
Calendars | 2016,
2017, 2018 |
2017, 2018 |
2017,
2018 |
2016,
2017, 2018 |
2016,
2017 |
2015, 2016, 2017 | 2015, 2016 | 2014, 2015 | 2017, 2018 | 2017 tiny on every facing pages. | 2016 Jul to Dec, 2017 |
Space Daily | thin ruled lines | plain,
hint for 4 parts |
plain box | plain box | plain, hint for 4 parts |
plain | Plenty. Ruled lines. | ||||
Moon phases | YES | NO | YES | ||||||||
week number | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | ||||||
International Holidays table | YES | YES | |||||||||
International Holidays | some | some | |||||||||
Next Year Planner |
YES | YES | YES | YES | |||||||
Personal info section | Full page | bottom corner near the end. | bottom corner near the end. | 2 pages | Last page | Almost last page. | |||||
Note paper | ruled | different styles & sizes, included traditional, perforated, etc. | 22 pages ruled | 30 pages ruled. | different styles & sizes, included traditional, perforated, etc. | 5 pages | 26 pages, checkered in fine light grey lines. | 17 ruled pages at back, plus 2 ruled pages after each month. | 1 page | 6 ruled pages, 1 blank page. | |
Special | Spirolux
system: 1- users can remove pages if needed to. 2- open flat. |
- Positive
quotations on week view pages. - Holidays have pink background colours. - Birth stone info on month- view pages. |
Positive
quotations on month-view & week-view pages |
Most spaces for writing are subtly checkered | Photos on the right hand side pages. | ||||||
Holidays list | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | ||||||
Festivals list | YES | YES | |||||||||
Lunar Calendar 24 key dates | YES | YES | |||||||||
age/year list # | YES | YES | |||||||||
Useful Tel | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | |||||
Emergency info | YES | YES | |||||||||
Conversions | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | ||||||
world map | Yes | Yes | |||||||||
National map | UK. colour. |
Japan , with prefectures | Japan | ||||||||
Other maps | YES | ||||||||||
Capital map | YES | - | |||||||||
Rail map of Capital | YES | YES | |||||||||
Rail maps of major cities in that country |
YES | YES | |||||||||
Capital Motorway/ Highway map |
YES | ||||||||||
Time zones | Yes | Yes | |||||||||
International holidays | Yes | Yes | |||||||||
IDD codes | Yes | YES | YES | ||||||||
Contacts/ Phone book |
4 pages | optional booklet attachment | / | / | optional booklet attachement | 10 pages A-Z | 6 pages | 2 pages | 2 pages | 6 pages | / |
Project Planning |
YES | ||||||||||
To Do list / checklist | Spaces | ruled spaces | Monthly | spaces | 6 pages | Various | |||||
Notable dates | YES | YES | YES | / | YES | YES | YES | YES | |||
manner/etiquette/social norm | YES | some | YES | ||||||||
Health/ personal care | Food. Exercises. Grooming/style, etc. | Health info of reflexology. | Recipes, exercises, etc. | ||||||||
Other pages / info | Travel
info, Birth Stones, Anniversaries, Various useful numbers |
Emergency packing checklist, Birth Stones, Anniversaries. Fav shopping list…. | Inland postage in Japan. | Fung Shui, anniversaries. Fav shopping list… | Birth Signs horoscope info. Anniversaries. Geometric formular. International paper sizes, spaces of useful contacts next to personal info. | Year Plan with different realms | Time-tables, Deadlines/ exams | Time-tables, Deadlines/ exams. Travel Info. Funding organisations, etc. | |||
Extras | Stickers & ruler bookmark | Stickers & ruler bookmark | |||||||||
Summary of product features removable printed sheet |
YES | Yes | YES | ||||||||
Paper | FSC paper | FSC paper | FSC MIX paper. one side matt one side slightly glossy reflective. | ||||||||
Page Edge index |
Tear-away type | Print on margin bleeding | Print on margin bleeding | ||||||||
Bookmark Ribbon | YES | YES | YES | ||||||||
Usage of colours in dairy |
gd | gd | reasonable | ok | gd | / | reasonable | gd | / | / | |
Made in | UK ? | Japan | Japan | ? | Japan | no data | Japan | Japan | UK | PRC | ? |
Project Team or Designers |
Ref info credited to various sources | Ref info credited to various sources |
Francesca // Robert Frederick Ltd. UK | photos are fully credited. | |||||||
Target
Audience !! |
Professionals who need to travel a lot. | Females in modern cities/towns from 20s to 40s. | Females aged twenties upwords. | Females aged twenties upwards | Females in modern cities/towns from 20s to 40s. | Females | Females | Professionals in Japan & alike | General public and senior citizens | Students | Students |
Comment | Professional to some extend. | GOOD. Thoughtful. . Nice size. Feminine. Practical. Well-designed | Lightweight. Simple. Casual | Lightweight, thin, simple. Not too practical as too small for writing. | GOOD. Thoughtful. Nice size. Feminine. Practical. Well-designed | Hard cover a bit heavy. | Lightweight. Simple. Casual | Professional image. | Metal spiral & heavy paper for home use. Nice photos. | Hard cover is heavy. Economical. | Metal sprial. Colourful. Economical. |
My suggestions |
Make a version for females. Reduce weight. | Add icons for moon phases. Make the healthy lifestyle reference section be separated & detachable. Try not to use PVC. | Try not to use PVC | Try not to use PVC | Add icons for moon phases. Make the healthy lifestyle reference section be separated & detachable. Try not to use PVC | Try not to use PVC | Add icons for moon phases. | ||||
My usage | TBC | as
pocket diary |
TBC | TBC | as pocket diary | due to its weight, used as notebook at home for expenses & vocabulary. | as pocket diary | as diary mainly for work life. | as notebook at home. | As
notebook at home. |
As
notebook for Bible verses at home. |
Price range | $$ | ** | $ | $ | ** | $$ | $ | $$-$$$ | $$ | $ | $ |
RRP | GBP6.35 ? | Present to customers | HKD12 | HKD12 | Present to customers | no data | HKD 10 | forgotten | GBP 7 | GBP 8 | no data |
Actual Price I paid | / | JPY 1000 plus postage | / | / | JPY 2000 plus postage | / | HKD 10 | forgotten | / | GBP 1 | GBP1 |
How I obtained | Gift | Bought | Gift | Gift | Bought | Gift | Bought | Bought | Gift | Bought | Bought |
Where from | friend | via an Japanese auction website | sister | sister | via an Japanese auction website | friend | Aeon (Living Plaza) | CitySuper or LogOn | friend | discount shop | discount shop |
* Most data refer to that country.
Most have smaller fonts. Over 50s may need reading glasses.
** Normally it is supposed to be a reward present for loyal customers
free of charge in that country.
P.S. I have also checked out other diaries in various shops;
also bought Moleskins(returned).
Most Taiwan, Hong Kong & PRC designs are not my cup of tea.
Too school-girly.
I apreciate international cosmopolitan functionality & also good tasteful design.
No comments:
Post a Comment
( feedback welcomed )